Serving Aurora, Denver Metro & Colorado | 15+ Years of DUI Defense
Lack of Actual Physical Control
Strategic Defense for Lack of Actual Physical Cases in Colorado
Lack of Actual Physical Control in Colorado DUI Cases
In Colorado, you can be arrested and charged with DUI even if police never saw you driving. Under Colorado DUI law, prosecutors may pursue charges based on a theory known as “actual physical control.” In many situations, this becomes one of the most important legal issues in a DUI case.
At The Lawrence Law Firm, our attorneys carefully evaluate whether law enforcement can actually prove a person exercised control over a vehicle under Colorado DUI law. In many cases, the surrounding facts are far more complicated than prosecutors initially claim. For a broader overview of Colorado DUI defense strategies, visit our Colorado DUI Defenses page.
What Is “Actual Physical Control” Under Colorado DUI Law?
Colorado’s DUI statute does not only prohibit “driving” while impaired. Instead, C.R.S. 42-4-1301 makes it illegal to:
- drive a vehicle while under the influence, or
- be in actual physical control of a vehicle while impaired.
This distinction is important because prosecutors do not necessarily need to prove the vehicle was moving. Instead, they may argue that the person had the present ability to operate or move the vehicle.
Colorado courts generally analyze actual physical control under a totality of the circumstances approach. One of the leading Colorado cases discussing this issue is People v. Swain, where the court explained that no single factor automatically determines whether actual physical control existed.
Instead, courts evaluate all surrounding circumstances.
Common Situations Involving Actual Physical Control
Actual physical control issues commonly arise in cases involving:
- sleeping in a parked vehicle after drinking,
- sitting in a vehicle with the keys nearby,
- warming up a vehicle in winter,
- waiting for a ride while inside a vehicle,
- intoxicated individuals found parked on the roadside,
- vehicles parked outside bars, restaurants, or homes,
- individuals attempting to “sleep it off.”
Many people incorrectly assume that choosing not to drive automatically prevents a DUI charge. Unfortunately, that is not always true under Colorado law.
Police officers often investigate whether the person still had the ability to operate the vehicle.
Factors Courts Consider in Actual Physical Control Cases
Colorado courts typically examine numerous factors when determining whether a person exercised actual physical control over a vehicle.
These may include:
Location of the Person Inside the Vehicle
Where was the person found?
- Driver’s seat
- Passenger seat
- Back seat
- Reclined position
- Outside the vehicle
Someone asleep in the driver’s seat may be viewed differently than someone sleeping in the back seat with blankets and the keys stored away.
Location of the Keys
The location and accessibility of the keys can become critically important.
Courts may examine whether:
- the keys were in the ignition,
- the keys were in the person’s pocket,
- the keys were inside the vehicle,
- the keys were outside the vehicle,
- the vehicle used push-button ignition,
- the vehicle could easily be started.
Whether the Engine Was Running
An engine running for heat or air conditioning may become a significant factor for prosecutors.
However, the engine running does not automatically prove guilt. The surrounding circumstances still matter.
Location of the Vehicle
Courts may also consider where the vehicle was located:
- parked legally,
- parked on the roadside,
- partially blocking traffic,
- parked in a parking lot,
- stuck in snow,
- disabled or inoperable.
A legally parked vehicle in a parking lot may create a very different factual scenario than a vehicle stopped in the middle of a roadway.
Vehicle Operability
If the vehicle could not realistically be operated, that may weaken the prosecution’s argument.
Issues involving:
- mechanical failure,
- dead batteries,
- lack of fuel,
- collision damage,
may become relevant in certain cases.
Request a Consultation
Can You Get a DUI for Sleeping in Your Car?
Possibly.
Colorado law does not contain a blanket exception for sleeping inside a vehicle after drinking. Prosecutors may still argue actual physical control existed depending on the facts.
However, sleeping in a vehicle also does not automatically mean a person is guilty.
These cases are often highly fact-specific.
For example, facts that may help support a defense argument can include:
- sleeping in the back seat,
- keys stored away from the ignition,
- no evidence the vehicle had recently been driven,
- legally parked vehicle,
- evidence the individual intended to avoid driving,
- arranging alternate transportation,
- lack of witness observations.
The central issue often becomes whether the person had the immediate ability and intent to operate the vehicle.
Police Investigations in Actual Physical Control Cases
Police officers frequently rely on circumstantial evidence in these investigations because they often never witnessed actual driving.
Officers may attempt to build the case through:
- admissions or statements,
- witness reports,
- engine warmth,
- hood temperature,
- vehicle positioning,
- open containers,
- surveillance footage,
- dispatch records,
- bar receipts,
- body camera footage,
- field sobriety tests,
- chemical testing evidence.
In many cases, statements made during the investigation become some of the most damaging evidence.
Officers are often trained to gather information before making an arrest. A person may believe they are simply “explaining what happened,” while unknowingly providing prosecutors with evidence used later in court.
Defending Actual Physical Control DUI Charges
At The Lawrence Law Firm, we analyze every aspect of these cases to determine whether prosecutors can actually prove actual physical control beyond a reasonable doubt.
Potential defenses may include:
Lack of Actual Physical Control
The defense may argue the person was not realistically capable of operating the vehicle at the time police encountered them.
No Evidence of Driving
In some cases, there may be little or no evidence establishing when the vehicle was driven, who drove it, or whether it was driven while impaired.
Illegal Police Contact or Unlawful Detention
Some actual physical control cases begin with questionable police encounters.
For example:
- welfare checks,
- anonymous tips,
- roadside encounters,
- parking lot investigations,
may raise constitutional issues involving unlawful detention or improper police contact.
Our firm carefully examines whether law enforcement violated constitutional protections during the investigation. Learn more about illegal DUI stops and motions to suppress.
Challenging Chemical Test Evidence
Even if prosecutors establish actual physical control, they must still prove impairment or intoxication.
Breath results and blood testing evidence may still be challenged based on:
- testing procedures,
- rising BAC issues,
- medical conditions,
- machine maintenance,
- blood draw procedures,
- timing issues.
You can learn more about:
DUI, DWAI, and Actual Physical Control
Actual physical control allegations may lead to:
- DUI charges,
- DUI per se charges,
- DWAI charges,
- drug-related DUI allegations.
The prosecution still must prove impairment under Colorado law.
To better understand the differences between these charges, visit:
DMV Consequences After an Actual Physical Control Arrest
Even if no accident occurred, a DUI arrest involving actual physical control may still trigger:
- license revocation proceedings,
- Express Consent consequences,
- DMV hearings,
- ignition interlock requirements.
Colorado DMV proceedings are separate from the criminal case.
You generally have only seven days to request a DMV hearing after receiving notice of revocation.
Learn more about:
Local DUI Defense Representation Across the Denver Metro Area
The Lawrence Law Firm represents clients facing DUI and actual physical control allegations throughout the Denver metro area, including:
Speak With a Colorado DUI Defense Attorney
If you have been arrested for DUI in Colorado, it is important to act quickly. Deadlines related to DMV hearings and evidence preservation may apply shortly after arrest.
To discuss your case with an experienced Colorado DUI defense lawyer, contact The Lawrence Law Firm for a free consultation.
Speak With A DUI Attorney Today
Free consultation • Flat Fees • Payment Plans Available
Contact Information
Address
2821 S. Parker Rd. Suite 865
Aurora, CO 80014
Contact
lain@coloradodefenders.com
Ph: 720-369-4929
Hours
Monday-Friday: 8 am - 6 pm
Weekends and Afterhours
By Appointment
Free Case Evaluation
Free Consultation. No Obligation. 100% Confidential.
