Paths in a Mountain - Is it worth hiring a personal injury attorney in Aurora, CO

Is It Worth Hiring a Personal Injury Attorney?

Schedule a Free Consultation

Short answer: usually, yes—if there are injuries, liability disputes, or real money at stake.

After a crash or other injury, you’re suddenly juggling medical visits, time off work, and calls from insurers who sound helpful but are trained to pay as little as possible.  Many people wonder, is it worth hiring a personal injury attorney after an accident? The truth is that legal representation often makes the difference in recovering full compensation

A good personal injury lawyer’s job is simple: raise the value of your claim, shorten the hassle, and protect you from mistakes—so your net recovery (what you keep after bills and fees) is higher than going it alone.

Below is a candid, Colorado-focused guide to when hiring counsel makes sense, what attorneys actually do behind the scenes, how fees work, and situations where you may not need a lawyer.

When hiring a PI lawyer is likely to increase your net recovery

  • You have medical treatment beyond a quick urgent-care visit. Imaging, PT/chiro, injections, or surgery? The insurer will scrutinize everything. Lawyers connect the dots between mechanism, diagnoses, and impairment—and stop lowball “soft-tissue” arguments.

  • Liability is disputed or unclear. Intersection crashes, lane changes, multiple vehicles, pedestrians/cyclists, or hit-and-run. We gather video, download vehicle data (EDR), measure the scene, and secure witnesses before evidence disappears.

  • There are multiple insurers. Think rideshare/commercial policies, your own UM/UIM, and MedPay. Sequencing claims correctly matters—a lot.

  • You have permanent injury or time away from work. Future care and reduced earning capacity must be documented with doctors (and sometimes vocational/economic experts). This is where DIY cases leave the most money on the table.

  • The insurer is stalling, denying, or “requesting more records” for months. Delay is a tactic. Attorneys force movement—up to and including a lawsuit.

  • There are liens/subrogation. Hospitals, health plans (ERISA, Medicare/Medicaid), and providers on liens all want a slice. We negotiate reductions so your net is maximized.

When you might not need a lawyer

  • Property damage only or very minor soreness that resolves in a few days and you don’t plan to treat.

  • The at-fault insurer is paying your repair, rental, and a small nuisance amount for inconvenience—and you’re comfortable signing a release.

If you’re unsure, a quick consult is better than guessing. We’ll tell you straight if you’re better off handling it yourself.

Request a Free Consultation

Is it worth hiring a personal injury attorney? Find out today.
Get In Touch Today

What a PI attorney actually does (beyond “sending a letter”)

  1. Locks down evidence early

    • Traffic/storefront/doorbell video canvass

    • EDR/telematics requests for vehicles and fleets

    • Scene measurements, signal timing, lighting/weather pulls

    • Witness outreach while memories are fresh

  2. Builds the medical proof

    • Creates a clean medical chronology (diagnoses, causation, impairment)

    • Coordinates specialist referrals when appropriate

    • Presents future care and restrictions credibly (no fluff—carriers hate fluff)

  3. Maps and sequences coverage

    • At-fault liability (personal or commercial)

    • UM/UIM (yours or a household member’s)

    • MedPay for immediate bills regardless of fault

    • Possible umbrella/excess policies

  4. Manages bills, liens, and paybacks

    • Hospital and provider liens, ERISA/Medicare/Medicaid subrogation

    • Negotiates down what’s owed so more of the settlement stays with you

  5. Negotiates—and litigates when needed

    • Delivers a demand package insurers respect (objective proof + human story)

    • If the offer is unfair, files suit, takes depositions, and pushes to trial

“Will a lawyer just take a big cut?” (How fees really work)

Most injury lawyers work on a contingency fee: you pay no attorney’s fee unless we win. The fee is a percentage of the recovery, plus case costs (filing, experts, records, etc.). The key question isn’t the fee in isolation—it’s your net after fees, costs, and medical paybacks.

A good firm earns its fee by:

  • Increasing the gross (better liability proof, documented damages)

  • Reducing what you owe (lien & subrogation negotiations)

  • Avoiding costly mistakes (bad statements, wrong medical framing, missed coverage)

We’re transparent about fees, costs, and your projected take-home. If we don’t think we can beat your DIY outcome, we’ll say so.

Timing: When should I call a lawyer?

  • Early is best—before recorded statements, before vehicle data is lost, and before the surveillance footage overwrites.

  • That said, if you’ve been trying to manage it and it’s dragging, it’s not too late. We can still course-correct, secure what remains, and push the file forward.

Common myths (and the truth)

  • “The at-fault insurer will be fair if I’m reasonable.”
    Adjusters are trained to minimize payouts. “Reasonable” without proof equals cheap.

  • “My imaging was normal, so I have no case.”
    Many injuries (including concussions and connective-tissue damage) are clinical diagnoses. Objective testing and consistent treatment matter more than one scan.

  • “If I hire a lawyer, it will take forever.”
    What takes forever is chasing adjusters without leverage. We move with purpose; if they stall, we litigate.

  • “Using MedPay/UM will hurt my premiums.”
    These are benefits you paid for. Using them correctly protects you and your claim. (We’ll review your policy specifics.)

What does the process look like?

  1. Free consultation
    We review facts, injuries, coverage, and next steps you can act on today.

  2. Evidence & claim setup
    Preservation letters, video canvass, EDR/telematics, witness outreach. We open claims in the right order.

  3. Treatment phase
    You focus on care; we organize records and bills and help with MedPay coordination. No gaps if you can help it—gaps invite doubt.

  4. Demand package
    Liability proof + medical proof + future needs + the human impact, presented cleanly.

  5. Negotiate or litigate
    Fair offer → done. Unfair offer → lawsuit, depositions, mediation, and trial if needed.

  6. Net recovery focus
    We negotiate liens and paybacks so more of the result stays with you.

How a lawyer can change the math (simple examples)

  • Disputed light case: DIY offer $8,000. After we obtain intersection video and witness statements + clarify medical causation, the carrier pays policy limits $50,000. We negotiate medical liens down by $6,000. Net meaningfully higher—even after fees/costs.

  • Hit-and-run: Client didn’t know UM benefits applied. We trigger UM, secure doorbell video, and establish impact. Result: a recovery that wouldn’t have existed DIY.

  • Commercial policy stacking: At-fault policy says “limits.” We identify an additional liable entity and umbrella coverage. Multiple layers open that weren’t on the table before.

(Every case is different; these are illustrative only.)

Colorado specifics you should know (high level, no legalese)

  • Comparative negligence: You can still recover if you’re less than 50% at fault; your recovery is reduced by your percentage. This is why evidence quality matters.

  • Deadlines: Colorado has strict time limits to file lawsuits (often 2–3 years, with special early notice rules for government entities). Don’t wait to ask.

How to choose the right PI lawyer

  • Evidence-first mindset. Ask how they secure video/EDR and build the medical record.

  • Net-recovery focus. Will they negotiate liens and explain your projected take-home?

  • Courtroom readiness. Will they actually file suit if the offer is unfair?

  • Access & communication. Do you get direct contact and clear updates?

  • Local experience. Familiar with Front Range courts and carriers (Aurora, Denver, Arapahoe, Adams, Jefferson, Douglas).

Personal Injury FAQs

Will I have to go to court?
Not necessarily. Many cases settle in the claims stage or during litigation (after depositions/mediation). We prepare like we’ll try the case—insurers notice.

What if I’m partly at fault?
We analyze liability and gather proof to reduce your share. You can often still recover if you’re under 50% at fault.

What if I don’t have health insurance?
We coordinate MedPay, and when appropriate, lien/letter-of-protection providers so you can keep treating while the claim is pending.

How long will it take?
Depends on medical recovery, liability clarity, and insurer behavior. We push the fastest path that doesn’t sacrifice value.

How much is my case worth?
Value depends on liability strength, medical proof, permanency, lost income, and available coverage. Anyone giving you a number before understanding those pieces is guessing.

Is it worth hiring a personal injury attorney?
Yes — a personal injury attorney can evaluate your case, handle insurance negotiations, and fight for compensation you may not secure on your own.

Common Personal Injury Cases We Handle

At our firm, we represent clients in a wide range of personal injury cases. Whether your injury was caused by a motor vehicle accident, unsafe property conditions, or another act of negligence, an experienced personal injury attorney can help protect your rights and pursue the compensation you deserve.

Some of the most common cases we handle include:

When you ask whether it is worth hiring a personal injury attorney, consider that each of these cases often involves complex insurance issues, medical evidence, and negotiations that are difficult to handle on your own. Having skilled legal representation ensures your case is taken seriously and your recovery is maximized.

Is it Worth Hiring a Personal Injury Attorney?

So, is it worth hiring a personal injury attorney? For most accident victims, the answer is yes — because the right lawyer can level the playing field against powerful insurance companies

If you have real injuries, disputed liability, multiple insurers, or medical bills, hiring a personal injury attorney is usually worth it—because the combination of stronger proof, smarter coverage strategy, and lien reductions tends to increase your net and reduce your stress.

The Lawrence Law Firm represents injured people across Aurora, Denver, and the Front Range (Arapahoe, Adams, Jefferson, and Douglas Counties). We’ll tell you straight if you need us—and if you don’t.

The American Bar Association gives helpful advise on finding the right lawyer and why representation matters. 

Schedule a Free Consultation

Areas of Practice

Protect Your Rights

Service Areas

  • Denver County
  • Arapahoe County
  • Adams County
  • Douglas County
  • Jefferson County

Request Free Consultation

Contact Information

Address

2821 S. Parker Rd. Suite 865 Aurora, CO 80014

Contact

lain@coloradodefenders.com Ph: 720-369-4929

Hours

Monday-Friday: 8 am - 6 pm Weekends and Afterhours By Appointment

Name(Required)
Please let us know how we can help. Someone from our office will reach out shortly.